4.NF.A.2 · Original instructional draft
I can compare unlike fractions and justify the comparison with a model.
Compare fraction numbers using common units or benchmarks, and compare pictured portions only when the reference wholes are consistent.
Success criteria
- Use equal reference wholes when comparing pictured amounts.
- Explain a comparison with common units, a benchmark or fraction size.
Before you begin: Explain unit sizes and equivalent fractions.
Understand the mathematics
Thirds, fourths and sixths are different units. Rename both amounts in a common unit or compare each with a useful benchmark. A larger denominator alone does not determine the larger fraction. Abstract fractions still have a numerical order even when physical pictures use different-sized wholes.
3/4 < 5/6, using equal-sized wholes.
Worked example
Compare 3/4 and 5/6 of equal-length strips.
- Use the same whole for both strips.
- Rename in twelfths: 3/4 = 9/12 and 5/6 = 10/12.
- Nine twelfths is less than ten twelfths, so 3/4 < 5/6. Both points fit on the same number line.
Compare fractions and their wholes
As numbers, 3/4 < 5/6. The same-sized wholes also let us compare the physical shaded amounts.
Use equal-sized fractional units
Try an amount greater than one. Count complete wholes before comparing the remaining pieces.
Check an example that does not fit
Choosing 5/6 only because 6 is larger than 4 does not justify a fraction comparison.
Diagnostic follow-up
What does one part measure in each model? Can you use a common unit or one half?
A single response does not diagnose a misconception. Ask for a drawing, unit, and explanation before deciding what support is needed.
Open math tools: counters, fractions, and a number line
Try an idea here. These tools do not fill in or check your answers.
One strip is one whole. All parts have the same area.
1/4 of the whole is shaded.
Keep the whole the same size. How many equal parts make one whole?
Your tool choices clear when this page reloads. You can use paper or objects instead.
Build procedural fluency
Compare 2/3 and 3/4.
Hint
Try twelfths.
Solution and explanation
2/3 = 8/12 < 9/12 = 3/4.
Explain: Why must the new pieces have the same size?
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Formative assessment
Which statement about the fraction numbers is true?
Hint
Compare one fifth with one eighth, or use one half as a benchmark.
Solution and explanation
With the same numerator and whole, three fifths are greater than three eighths.
Explain: Explain without constructing fortieths.
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Apply in a new situation
Two equal one-meter ribbons have 2/5 and 1/2 marked. Which marked length is longer?
Hint
Use equal wholes and tenths, or compare with one half.
Solution and explanation
1/2 = 5/10 is greater than 2/5 = 4/10.
Explain: What extra information would you need if the full ribbons had different lengths?
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Source evidence
4.NF.A.2. Original instructional interpretation, not an official assessment item or endorsed lesson. Catalog identifiers were checked against supplied PDFs; instructional source verification and independent mathematics, educator and accessibility reviews remain pending. One example does not cover the full standard.