4.NBT.B.4 · Original instructional draft
I can explain exchanges in multi-digit addition and subtraction.
The standard algorithms align place units and regroup equivalent amounts when adding or subtracting.
Success criteria
- Align like place-value units.
- Show that each regrouping preserves the original value.
Before you begin: Compose and decompose hundreds and thousands without changing value.
Understand the mathematics
Regrouping changes the units used to represent a number, not the number itself. Addition records a new group in the place to the left. Subtraction may exchange a larger unit for ten smaller ones, even across empty places.
| Quantity | Thousands | Hundreds | Tens | Ones |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Addend 1 | 3 | 8 | 6 | 7 |
| Addend 2 | 2 | 5 | 8 | 6 |
| Sum | 6 | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| 6004 exchanged | 5 | 9 | 9 | 14 |
| Subtract | 2 | 7 | 8 | 6 |
| Difference | 3 | 2 | 1 | 8 |
Each exchange preserves value: 5 × 1000 + 9 × 100 + 9 × 10 + 14 × 1 = 6004. Read the worked steps to explain each carried or exchanged unit.
Worked example
Use place value to explain 3,867 + 2,586 and 6,004 − 2,786.
- Addition: 7 + 6 = 13 ones. Record 3 ones and carry 1 ten; continue with tens, hundreds and thousands to get 6,453.
- For subtraction, exchange 6,004 as 5 thousands, 9 hundreds, 9 tens and 14 ones. The amount is still 6,004.
- Subtract corresponding units to get 3 thousands, 2 hundreds, 1 ten and 8 ones: 3,218. Check 3,218 + 2,786 = 6,004.
Check an example that does not fit
Taking the smaller digit from the larger in every column ignores which whole number is being subtracted.
Diagnostic follow-up
What amount did the exchange represent before and after? Can you check using the inverse operation?
A single response does not diagnose a misconception. Ask for a drawing, unit, and explanation before deciding what support is needed.
Build, explain, and show your mathematical work
Build a model. Try a problem. Tell someone how you worked it out. Your answers stay on this page and clear on reset or refresh.
Expectation-level coverage and remaining gaps
Open math tools: counters, fractions, and a number line
Try an idea here. These tools do not fill in or check your answers.
2 groups × 3 counters = 6 counters.
Change one count. What changed in your picture?
Explore groups and arrays in the learning pathway →Your tool choices clear when this page reloads. You can use paper or objects instead.
Align digits and make value-preserving exchanges
Place each digit of 1647 into its named column. Then build the exchanges needed for the standard algorithm. Enter final digits yourself. For standard addition, process ones, then tens, then hundreds. On narrow screens, scroll the table horizontally to see every place.
| Row | 1,000s | 100s | 10s | 1s |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting number | 2 | 7 | 8 | 6 |
| Align 1647 | ||||
| Combined units | 2 | 7 | 8 | 6 |
| Your result |
Represented value: 2,786. This is the combined value after placing both addends.
Check the digits against the place units after trading. A correct final numeral without the recorded alignment and exchanges does not satisfy this model task.
Explain and review with a person
Say your idea aloud or draw it first. You can ask a parent or teacher to listen. Typing below is optional.
Writing is never automatically scored. An educator should compare the mathematical connections, units and justification with these original criteria. Empty or incorrect explanations are not marked correct by checking boxes.
Original exemplar and another valid approach
13 ones become 1 ten and 3 ones. The carried ten makes 13 tens, which become 1 hundred and 3 tens. Then 14 hundreds become 1 thousand and 4 hundreds. The result is 4,433. Each exchange preserves value.
Another approach: 2,700 + 1,600 = 4,300 and 86 + 47 = 133, so the total is 4,433. This checks the value using a different method.
Explain an independent subtraction
Calculate 5,003 − 1,768. An incorrect solution gives 4,765 by subtracting the smaller digit from the larger in each column.
Original structured task · 4.NBT.B.4 · Educator review pending. This task checks entered values and structures. Written reasoning is reviewed separately.
Original entered-part reference
- Thousands after exchanging across the zeros: 4
- Hundreds after exchanging across the zeros: 9
- Tens after exchanging across the zeros: 9
- Ones after exchanging across the zeros: 13
- Difference in whole units: 3235
- Compare two valid approaches to the difference.: Both preserve the difference and give the same result.
- Write an addition check using 3235 and 1768.: Both sides name 5003; use the stated quantities 3235, 1768 in the relationship. Follow the operation requested in the prompt.
This reference checks the requested entries. It does not evaluate a written explanation or certify the student’s method.
Explain and review with a person
Say your idea aloud or draw it first. You can ask a parent or teacher to listen. Typing below is optional.
Writing is never automatically scored. An educator should compare the mathematical connections, units and justification with these original criteria. Empty or incorrect explanations are not marked correct by checking boxes.
Original exemplar and another valid approach
5,003 = 4 thousands + 9 hundreds + 9 tens + 13 ones. Subtracting 1,768 leaves 3,235. Digitwise larger-minus-smaller changes the meaning of subtraction.
Another approach: Compensation: 5,003 − 1,700 = 3,303, then subtract 68 to get 3,235. Both methods preserve the original difference; this alternate method alone does not demonstrate the standard algorithm.
Source scope: supplied Grade 4 NMIS 3.0 standard panels. All prompts, diagrams, feedback and review criteria here are original. Assessment references and verification limits are recorded in the coverage crosswalk. Independent content and educator review remain pending.
Build procedural fluency
Calculate 2,468 + 1,795.
Hint
Align ones with ones and track every carry.
Solution and explanation
The sum is 4,263; exchanges carry into the next column.
Explain: Explain one exchange in your algorithm.
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Formative assessment
Calculate 5,002 − 1,847.
Hint
Exchange through the zero places before subtracting.
Solution and explanation
5,002 − 1,847 = 3,155; check by adding 1,847.
Explain: Why does the represented value stay 5,002?
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Apply in a new situation
A library had 4,350 books and received 875 more. How many books does it have now?
Hint
Use aligned columns and check with an estimate.
Solution and explanation
4,350 + 875 = 5,225 books.
Explain: Which exchanges occurred?
Discuss or sketch your reasoning. Explanations need a person to review them; a correct answer alone does not show complete understanding.
Source evidence
4.NBT.B.4. Original instructional interpretation, not an official assessment item or endorsed lesson. Catalog identifiers were checked against supplied PDFs; instructional source verification and independent mathematics, educator and accessibility reviews remain pending. One example does not cover the full standard.